Ansel Adams is, of course, famous for his black and white photos of the American landscape. Whenever I’ve looked at his black and white images I’ve always thought of them as well-crafted and well-composed but very stark and, frankly, somewhat flat, lifeless and closed in. There isn’t a lot there that really moves or inspires me aside from the stark graphic forms. I’ve always wondered in the back of my mind what they would look in color. Well, now I found out.
Recently I saw a book in Barnes and Noble called Ansel Adams in Color. I don’t remember ever seeing his color photographs before so looking at the photos in this book really shows me a different side of him. To me the photos in this book are very alive and visually interesting compared to his black and white images. They really are kind of a relief to me compared to the somewhat heavy black and whites. The colors maybe aren’t quite what our modern eyes would expect, being used to modern digital images, but they still add a great deal to the images.
I have to admit that I am somewhat biased against black and white. I can see that it has its uses but it just generally doesn’t seem all that interesting to me. As I said above, the stark graphic aspect can be interesting with the right subject but the images generally seem flat and lifeless with a very heavy and closed in feel. Very little subtlety. Color seems to me to add a whole new dimension that makes the images feel much more alive and open. Color is just an overwhelmingly important part of the way we see the world and removing it just provides a very impoverished view. I realize there are many people that would disagree with this, but it just seems obvious to me and I feel that black and white is rather overrated.
There seems to be a little bit of controversy about this particular book too. Apparently Ansel was fairly clear that he felt these color images didn’t live up to his standards and that he didn’t want them published. At least part of this seems to be because of the limitations of the color films and developing process in use at the time. I have seen a few comments, particularly in the customer reviews for the book on Amazon, saying that the images shouldn’t have been published in this book for that reason. I have to say that, while I understand the reasoning, I don’t agree. First, if nothing else these pictures have a significant historical interest that makes publishing them worthwhile. Also, to me at least, these color pictures are actually much better than the black and white ones. It would really be a shame to lose all that.